Day on Torts

Summary judgment for plaintiff in conversion case affirmed.

Where defendant in a conversion case admitted all of plaintiff’s statement of facts and only asserted in his additional facts that he acted in good faith and honesty, summary judgment for plaintiff on the conversion claim was affirmed.

In Melton v. Melton, No. E2023-00649-COA-R3-CV (Tenn. Ct. App. Dec. 27, 2023), plaintiff was the personal representative of his mother’s estate, and he filed this breach of fiduciary duty and conversion claim against his brother both in his capacity as personal representative and his individual capacity. The facts showed that a few months before the mother’s death, defendant had traveled to her home in Tennessee and had the mother execute a power of attorney naming defendant her attorney-in-fact. In the weeks before the mother’s death, defendant drained the mother’s bank accounts, purchasing multiple vehicles and a recreational vehicle for himself, cashing checks to himself, and only paying one small bill for the mother. One of these accounts was payable to plaintiff brother on death, and the others would have gone to the estate.

Plaintiff filed a motion for summary judgment supported by a detailed statement of material facts. Defendant responded by admitting all of plaintiff’s facts, and filing only one additional material fact which stated that defendant “at all times acted with the utmost good faith, honesty, and loyalty to his mother…” The trial court ruled that defendant had not created an issue of material fact and granted plaintiff summary judgment, and the Court of Appeals affirmed.

Recent Articles: