The Quick and Easy Way to Make Pumpkin (or Other) Popcorn We're making this scrumptious popcorn with a syrup mix! In this case, with our new Pumpkin Cream Pancake Syrup Mix. We're popping a generous half-cup of popcorn. We're making the syrup according to directions but cooking it two minutes longer, and then stirring it into the popcorn. That's it! Save 44%! Get four syrup mixes for $9.99. Regular $4.49 each.Save 20% on all pancake mixes.