Email
You will see Labor and the Coalition and the Greens put big reassuring price tags on their policies with assurances they are fully costed. But are they? Joe Hildebrand isn’t convinced.
View in browser 19th April 2025
 

image

Joe Hildebrand
Federal election correspondent

A beloved reader sent me a message this morning: Hey Joe, you are so incredibly cool and handsome and all-knowing about all-things, how come the opposition never release their costings til just before election day?

I may have slightly paraphrased the first part but the second is an incredibly good question and something that very few members of the public even notice, let alone ask.

Election costings are something that is usually left for newspaper journos to desperately tally up each day and economists to roll their eyes at.

Quite frankly, they don’t add up. And I mean they literally don’t add up.

This is true even of governments and even more so of oppositions. And when it comes to minor parties and independents we are talking about numbers that are simply plucked from the air — or perhaps some other darker and less hygienic place.

And that’s because during an election campaign you are always going to want to promise more than you can possibly deliver and so you have to obscure your capacity to deliver as much as possible.

Thus you will see Labor and the Coalition and the Greens put big reassuring price tags on their policies with assurances they are fully costed. But are they?

Is the cost a one-off for a single year or is it recurring? And if it is recurring is it a cost across the forward estimates period — four years — or across a decade, which even the Budget doesn’t pretend to be able to predict?

imageBrett Lethbridge takes a look at the Easter preference hunt.

CHECK OUT MORE GREAT CARTOONS HERE

Often you will see all these numbers rolled into a single figure, even though they apply to completely different types of spending across completely different time periods.

Indeed, the closest you can get to any credible breakdown of spending is the Budget itself, but even there you will see billions of dollars missing for “measures taken but not yet announced” — i.e. election promises.

In other words, it’s all bunkum.

 CLICK HERE FOR JOE HILDEBRAND'S FULL ANALYSIS

Election update
‘They don’t add up’: Big problem major parties face
You will see Labor and the Coalition and the Greens put big reassuring price tags on their policies with assurances they are fully costed. But are they? Joe Hildebrand isn’t convin...
READ MORE  
PM’s ‘Vegemite-gate’ win, sledge against ‘Dutton dressed as lamb’
Anthony Albanese has revealed Australia has had a win on “Vegemite-gate”, as Peter Dutton was attacked over his work from home policy. FOLLOW LIVE
READ MORE  
Explosive toll of Labor’s nuclear scare campaign as Dutton’s vote collapses
Anthony Albanese’s nuclear scare campaign is decimating the Coalition’s primary vote, with Peter Dutton possibly picking up one seat in a battleground state, an exclusive new poll ...
READ MORE  

VIDEO OF THE DAY

image

VOTER VERDICT: Bare cupboards before payday, being forced to work two jobs and no nights out – undecided voters have laid bare the sacrifices they are making amid the cost-of-living crisis.

 WATCH THE VIDEO HERE

image

Read more
Clive Palmer’s shocking ballot plan for Labor and Liberals
Clive Palmer’s Trumpet of Patriots is set to have a damaging effect on the Coalition, according to one pollster, with support for the minor party expected to fracture primary votes...
READ MORE  
Sabrina Carpenter and Home Alone star’s wild election cameo
Labor and the Liberals are embracing the weird, wacky and just plain cringe this election campaign. WATCH THE BEST (AND WORST)
READ MORE  
Bare cupboards, working six days a week: Aussies tell of costs crisis
The heartbreaking reality of the cost of living crisis has been revealed by everyday Australians who say they are struggling to put food on the table while some haven’t been out fo...
READ MORE  
‘I don’t know who to vote for’: Election MatchMaker is here to help
Having trouble wading through the parties’ promises, or just can’t decide what’s real and what’s spin? Election MatchMaker is here to help. USE THE INTERACTIVE TOOL NOW
READ MORE  
Best of our election race cartoons
These are the best illustrations from our cartoonists who capture the funny side of what’s going on in the federal election race. SEE THE PICTURES
READ MORE  
LISTEN NOW: NDIS Minister Amanda Rishworth’s Spotify list
We have asked Australia’s MPs what their top five songs are on the election trail and NDIS Minister Amanda Rishworth has revealed what’s on her list. Listen now.
READ MORE  
Full list: Where to vote early in the federal election
Australia will head to the polls on May 3 to vote for the next federal government. Here is everything you need to know about voting early.
READ MORE  
Labor masterstroke points to a chainsaw massacre
If the polls are right, this election isn’t going to be close – it’s going to be a chainsaw massacre. When asking why, it’s hard to go past nuclear, writes James Campbell.
READ MORE  
PM’s update on Oscar Jenkins before he stands trial
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has said his government has not abandoned Oscar Jenkins, amid reports the Australian is now facing criminal charges for being a mercenary.
READ MORE  
200,000: The number Albo and Dutton need to solve housing crisis
Anthony Albanese and Peter Dutton need to do more to solve our housing crisis — and experts say there’s a key number they need to hit.
READ MORE  
Albo’s plan to protect penalty rates for 3m Aussie workers
Penalty rates for three million workers on awards will be protected under an Albanese government pledge that reignites an election fight over industrial relations.
READ MORE  
Six BS claims from Albo and Dutton debunked
Green hydrogen doesn’t work, Albanese is spending more than Whitlam, and investors hate nuclear — we break down the spin to bring you the facts from the election campaign trail.
READ MORE  
Revealed: Dutton’s massive tax promise to small business
Peter Dutton has announced a new tiered tax offset system under a generous Coalition policy to help Aussie small business owners. Here’s what he is proposing.
READ MORE  

Newsletter

AS NEEDED
Breaking News Alert
Never miss a story that matters to you. Get informed as important news breaks in SA and around the world.
Newsletter sign-up   ▸

Newsletter

DAILY
Sport Daily
Love your sport? Catch up with fresh news and exclusive reports every morning.
Newsletter sign-up   ▸

Newsletter

Every Tuesday
SA Business Journal
Your weekly digest of the stories that matter to South Australian businesses and consumers.
Newsletter sign-up   ▸
The Advertiser app: SA’s best news now has daily recipes too
The Advertiser’s app for smartphones and tablets is the best way to stay in touch with the news in South Australia – and now we can inspire your cooking and baking, too.
READ MORE