Email
Jacinta Price insists she unintentionally channeled Donald Trump, as talk of a Labor and Greens alliance resurfaces. FOLLOW LIVE
View in browser 12th April 2025
 

image

Joe Hildebrand
Federal election correspondent

The Ancient Roman magistrate Lucius Cassius had a simple test for determining the source of any skulduggery or scuttlebutt: “Cui bono” or “Who benefits?”

Two thousand years later, it is still a vital rule of thumb in politics. Every piece of information you read and hear is there for a reason. Who is it coming from, and why do they want it out there?

If, for example, polling commissioned by a candidate shows that the candidate is doing very well, it’s probably best that you take those numbers with a barrel full of salt.

Likewise, if polling commissioned by a particular interest group shows that its interests align uncannily with the electorates, you might want to wash that down with a spoonful of sodium chloride as well.

Often, such “information” is released in an effort to make it a self-fulfilling prophecy. A low-profile candidate is presented as a dark horse, and suddenly people start paying attention to them and their chances of winning thus improve.

Recent polling about Chris Bowen’s seat of McMahon fits squarely in this category.

Likewise by releasing figures saying how worried the electorate is about something raises the profile of that issue and thus makes the electorate more worried about it. 

Ever wondered why everybody’s suddenly talking about an endangered fish in Tasmanian salmon farms that no one had ever heard of before?

A tantalising poll has shown Peter Dutton was set to lose his seat because of a “toxic” issue in his Brisbane electorate of Dickson.

The survey of 854 voters conducted by UComms showed Labor’s Ali France was ahead of Dutton 52-48 two-party preferred.

And that “toxic” issue? Apparently, 46 per cent of respondents said, "they were less likely to vote for Dutton due to his plan to build nuclear reactors”.

And who commissioned the survey? The Queensland Conservation Council.

Now I’m no psychic, but I’ve got a feeling that the Queensland Conservation Council is not particularly pro-nuclear.

Of course, there are no plans for a nuclear reactor in the seat of Dickson, but that is beside the point, which is: Nuclear bad, Dutton in trouble.

image

VOTE NOW: 10 best cartoons of the 2025 federal election campaign

But let’s not throw the baby out with the bathwater, however radioactive it might be.

Because, almost a week before this poll was released, I was told by senior Labor figures that Dutton really is in a world of pain in his own seat, which the ALP is throwing baby, bathwater and the kitchen sink at.

And given the Opposition Leader holds it by just 1.7 per cent — making it the most marginal seat in Queensland — it is entirely possible, based on the latest national polls.

Normally, you would expect a swing against the government at its second outing, and a bit of extra padding if the local MP is the potential future PM, but this election appears to be heading in the other direction.

And of course, just publicly raising the prospect that Dutton could lose his seat could increase the likelihood of it happening — soft and undecided voters may see which way the majority of their community is leaning and figure they may as well go with the flow.

That’s the only nuclear reaction at risk of occurring in that electorate.

CLICK HERE FOR JOE HILDEBRAND'S FULL ANALYSIS.

Election update
Price channels Trump as Dutton goes after PM on Greens alliance
Jacinta Price insists she unintentionally channeled Donald Trump, as talk of a Labor and Greens alliance resurfaces. FOLLOW LIVE
READ MORE  
Shock new poll reveals Dutton’s dodgy start to election campaign
Fresh polling has shown the damage done by Peter Dutton’s shaky start to the federal election campaign — but voters are not behaving how you’d think.
READ MORE  
Dutton’s election danger zone: A nuclear reaction at risk
Just publicly raising this election threat that Peter Dutton faces could increase the likelihood of it happening, argues Joe Hildebrand.
READ MORE  

VIDEO OF THE DAY

imageAnthony Albanese and Peter Dutton visit Perth as the Federal Election campaign continues.

WATCH THE VIDEO HERE image

Read more
Latest election odds revealed
Labor’s chances of retaining power continue to grow by the day, according to the latest odds. See where the PM and Peter Dutton stand.
READ MORE  
‘Painful’: Furious backlash over election ‘lies’, ‘dumb ideas’
Readers remain torn over our next prime minister, with furious debate continuing just weeks out from the election. HAVE YOUR SAY
READ MORE  
‘Seen this movie before’: Dutton blasts threat to own seat
Peter Dutton has doubled down again on claims he could be in trouble in his own marginal electorate of Dickson.
READ MORE  
The most telling fact about the Teals campaign
The majority of Climate 200 backed candidates are running in electorates held by the Coalition including seats held by senior Liberals including Peter Dutton and Sussan Ley.
READ MORE  
Albo’s been rubbish but Dutton, stop the Grim Reaper act
Anthony Albanese is far more popular than Peter Dutton. If the Opposition wants to win, they need to sort themselves out quickly, writes James Campbell.
READ MORE  
WATCH: Bizarre rant from western Sydney Muslim candidate

Jewish groups have expressed alarm at a sermon by a pro-Gaza federal election candidate in which he told worshippers at a Western Sydney mosque: “I felt like I was dead and 7th ...

READ MORE  
Jewish leaders call on Climate 200 to come clean
Jewish leaders are calling on the major financial donor to the Teal political movement, Climate 200, to clarify the body’s position on Israel – after two staff members publicly exp...
READ MORE  
Coalition warns of Labor Greens $90b super tax bomb
A Labor Greens alliance would deliver a $90 billion per year superannuation “tax bomb” on young Australians by the time they retired, the Coalition has claimed.
READ MORE  
Full list: Where to vote early in the federal election
Australia will head to the polls on May 3 to vote for the next federal government. Here is everything you need to know about voting early.
READ MORE  
LISTEN NOW: Aussie MP who has Tupac on their Spotify list
We have asked Australia’s MPs what their top five songs are on the election trail and one of them enjoys listening to Tupac. Listen now.
READ MORE